Pellet Grill vs Gas Grill: Two Tools, Two Jobs
I've cooked on both for the better part of two decades, and here's the short version: a gas grill is a high-heat searing machine that happens to live in your yard, and a pellet grill is a low-and-slow oven that happens to burn wood. They're not competitors. They're different tools for different jobs, and if you only buy one, you're going to be stuck crouching over a gas flame at 7 AM trying to hold 225°F while your brisket stalls. I've been there. It doesn't work. But before you drop $800 on a pellet grill, let me walk you through what I've learned from twenty years of logs, fourteen years of KCBS judging, and a garage full of half-disassembled smokers.
Best Overall: Traeger Pro Series
The Traeger is the benchmark for a reason. When owners say "outstanding quality on par with my Traeger," that's the highest compliment a pellet grill can receive, and I've seen it in review after review across the budget brands. The Pro Series holds temperature better than anything else I've tested in this class, and the smoke flavor actually smothers the meat instead of escaping through vent holes like some cheaper units I've had on my bench. My wife, who only tolerates mild smoke, actually asked for seconds on a pork shoulder I cooked with Traeger apple pellets. That never happens.
Is it perfect? No. The built-in probe is a coin flip, same as every other manufacturer. Budget for a ThermoPro TP20 and don't look back. And on a cold, windy day, the Pro Series will struggle a little, but hell, who doesn't. At around $800 for the 22-inch model, you're paying for reliability, and in my experience, that's worth every penny. [Check price on Amazon]
Best Value: Pit Boss Austin XL
The Pit Boss Austin XL is the grill I recommend when someone tells me they want a pellet smoker but they don't want to remortgage the house. At roughly $450, you get 1,000 square inches of cooking space, a hopper that holds 19 pounds of pellets, and a slide-plate searing feature that gives you a ripping direct flame for steaks. That's a whole lot of grill for the money.
I've put three briskets through this unit, and the meat came out right every single time, even when the display was lying to me. Set it for 180°F once and my ThermoPro read 240°F. But here's the thing: the bark set, the smoke ring formed, and the meat was the final judge. It passed. The Austin XL is the poor man's brisket champion, and if you're not ready for a full packer, this is the grill to learn on. [Check price on Amazon]
Best for Portability: Cuisinart 8-in-1
The Cuisinart 8-in-1 is crazy good for the price. I've tested it alongside the Onlyfire GS313, and for a tabletop unit, it punches well above its weight class. One owner I talked to called it their favorite of three pellet grills, praising the efficiency and the smoke output. On my first cook, I got a smoke ring on a 3-pound chuck roast that I'd expect from a $1,200 unit. The meat came out right even though the display was lying to me the whole time.
But here's the caveat, and it's a big one. There's a documented thermal runaway incident from a verified buyer back in June. The paint bubbled. The insulating felt melted. The controller went rogue and fed pellets until flames shot out the back slots under pressure like a forge. His wife yelled "the smoker is on fire." And when he contacted the manufacturer about the warranty, they denied it because he used foil on the heat shield. Everyone I know wraps their heat deflector in foil. That could've been me. I recommend this grill with a caveat emptor. If you buy it, check the fire pot after every cook, and don't expect the warranty to cover anything. [Check price on Amazon]
Best for Searing: Gas Grill
If your primary job is cooking steaks, burgers, and chicken thighs at high heat, a gas grill is the right tool. There's no pellet grill on the market that can match a gas grill's ability to hit 500°F in ten minutes and hold it there. My Weber Spirit has been running for eight years without a single repair. It's not a smoker. It will never produce a real smoke ring. But if you want a ripping direct flame for a ribeye, a gas grill does the job without the learning curve.
The problem is when people try to use a gas grill for low and slow. You can't hold 225°F on a gas grill without babysitting it constantly, and even then, you're not getting real smoke flavor. I've seen people try to fake it with a smoke box full of wood chips, and the result is always the same: lightly kissed, not smoky bark. If you're only going to cook burgers and steaks, buy gas. If you want brisket, you need pellets.
How I Tested
I ran these units through the same gauntlet I've used for every pellet grill I've owned: a 14-hour pork shoulder on an 8-pound shoulder, a poor man's brisket on a 3-pound chuck roast, and a 21-pound turkey on Thanksgiving. I logged the outside temp, the wind, the pellet brand, the set temp, the actual temp from my ThermoPro TP20, and the hold times. I cooked in July and I cooked in January, because a smoker that holds temp beautifully in summer will show its true character on a cold, windy day.
I packed and unpacked the portable units, carried them from the garage to the deck and back, and ran them through multiple cooks to see how the fire pot held up. I cleaned the fire pots after every three to four short cooks, because if you don't, you're asking for trouble. I've seen thermal runaway. I've seen fire travel back up the auger into the hopper. I don't want to see it again.
Analysis and Test Results
Temperature Accuracy
Every pellet grill I've tested has a temperature discrepancy. The display lies. One owner set 180°F and measured 210-250°F. Another set 180°F and hit 260°F+. Multiple owners independently confirm this is a known issue across every brand. But here's the thing: the temperature swings don't seem to matter in the end. The meat comes out right anyway. That's not an excuse for a manufacturer to ship a lying display, but it's a reason not to panic when your smoker misbehaves. The meat is the final judge, not the digital display.
Fire Pot Maintenance
The fire pot is the soul of the machine. If you don't clean it, you're risking a fire. The Traeger and Pit Boss both have fire pots that are relatively easy to access, which means you'll actually clean them. The Cuisinart's fire pot is smaller and harder to reach, which is a problem. On a long cook, the ash buildup can restrict airflow, and that's when things go sideways.
Hopper Capacity
The Traeger Pro Series holds 18 pounds of pellets, which means you can sleep through the night on a brisket cook. The Pit Boss Austin XL holds 19 pounds, same story. The Cuisinart 8-in-1 has a small hopper. Figure on feeding it every 4 hours on a long cook. That's manageable for a tabletop unit, but it's a dealbreaker if you want to set it and forget it.
Smoke Flavor
This is where pellet grills separate themselves from gas. Too many vent holes let smoke escape rather than smothering the meat. The Traeger and Pit Boss both do a solid job of trapping smoke. The Cuisinart does too, surprisingly. Apple and cherry woods are the wife-friendly woods. She actually asked for seconds on the Traeger cook. That's the highest praise I can give.
What Else to Consider
The Onlyfire GS313 is a mixed bag. One owner calls it their favorite of three pellet grills, praising efficiency and the direct-flame searing feature. Another reports fans failing, temps stuck under 200°F, and fire shooting out the side. At 35 pounds, it's "portable" in the sense that it has handles. That's not portable. That's "I can move it with a dolly." At around $200, it's a value-priced gamble. I'd want to see a temperature log before I trusted it with a brisket. [Check price on Amazon]
Should You Buy a Pellet Grill?
If you want real barbecue, yes. A pellet grill is the closest thing to a set-and-forget smoker that exists, and the meat it produces is legitimately good. If you're only cooking burgers and steaks, buy a gas grill and save your money. But if you want brisket, pork shoulder, or anything that requires low and slow, a pellet grill is the right tool for the job.
If you buy one, budget for a ThermoPro and a pack of foil. Trust me. And clean your fire pot. I've seen what happens when you don't, and it's not pretty. My name is Joe, and this is smokerbench.
Like This Guide?
Get our best dog bed recommendations delivered every Friday. Join 1,200+ dog owners.